Welcome to the unofficial CanadianIdol.info site! Click for the official CTV Canadian Idol website
Last update: August 23rd, 2005
This year we've managed to retain our "Ravin' Reviewer" to review every episode of Canadian Idol 3. Please see TV-Schedule for dates and episode specifics.
Episodes: (Click an episode number to read the review)
Top-05 Performance "Tribute to Burton
Cummings and The Guess Who"
Well I’m back this week and I must
say I am surprised Canada that you watched Josh leave last week. I must
say I am not one his biggest fan but why is Casey still here? She is a
sweet girl but come on folks, it’s her time to go before we lose the
better talented Idols. Maybe they are using the same earplugs as the
judges do some weeks who knows!
01. Rex Goudie
I like this song and
it seems like a good choice for him. The start was a little abrupt but
as the song went on it was great. He drew in the crowd and played a bit
with the song. Wasn’t his best week but overall was good. I like how he
sings for the audience and makes them feel like they are part of it. 8
out of 10.
02. Casey LeBlanc
This week I will
admit that Casey has grown in her voice and her style but I don’t think
it’s enough to go on to next week. The voice range just isn’t there. She
is weak when it comes to singing low range. She doesn’t have the power
to pull out the notes to get that song out so you can hear it. Casey
needs to go home this week so that the people that can sing better won’t
go before her. It’s really not personal. I think she will do great in a
few years but just not right now. 7 out of 10.
03. Suzi Rawn
Great choice for Suzi
this week! It’s kind of rock and I know she will pull it off. I like the
different flare she put on it. She apparently did the Lenny Kravitz
version. As I haven’t heard it, I don’t know it, so I will say I like
the way she sang this song. It was a bit slow in spots but otherwise the
vocals were there. She looks good in her clothes and she is having fun
which I think a lot of them forget to do. Kick up them legs and have a
blast Suzi because you ROCK! 8 out of 10.
04. Melissa O'Neil
My, my, my… what can
I say about that? Melissa was great on the vocal part but the song
wasn’t all that. I think she should have sung Stand Tall. That would
have showcased her voice so much better. As for the clothes: WHAT IS
GOING ON? I have said from the start that she needs someone to dress her
and if he has someone now she needs someone new! Zack took the words
right out of my mouth. She is star material but get an outfit please. 8
for the vocals and 4 for the outfit.
05. Aaron Walpole
Way to go Aaron!!!!!
That was totally off the wall. Aaron looked great and held onto that
song perfectly. He showed a side of himself that was great. He has the
ability to sing just about anything. I believe Aaron will give these
people the best show of the year. He’s Idol material for sure and I know
I would buy his CD right now. 9 out of 10.
In my opinion, the
This site is not affiliated with CTV or the producers of Canadian Idol.
It's an independent site by Canadian Idol fans for Canadian Idol fans.